MLegal | November 2026
The theme for this year’s Islamophobia Awareness Month is “Don’t Let It Slide”. We are publishing a new article exploring how unevenly Islamophobia and other forms of racialised religious bigotry is addressed in the UK.
On paper, the United Kingdom offers a single, universal guarantee of religious liberty. In practice, however, decades of statutory provisions, case law and now inconsistent government-sponsored non-statutory definitions have produced something closer to a four-tier system of protection for groups facing racialised religious bigotry. Buddhists, Christians, Hindus, Jews, Muslims and Sikhs are protected by significantly different legal and policy mechanisms which require markedly different evidential standards.
By ‘racialised religious bigotry’ we mean hostility directed at people not simply for what they believe, but because they are perceived as belonging, by birth, descent or some other characteristic, to a religious community. A non-religious Muslim may still be targeted as a Muslim on grounds of their name or appearance.
Hostility towards both Jewish and Muslim communities is currently at record levels. In the year to March 2026, Jewish people faced the highest rate of religious hate crime relative to the size of their community, and Muslims were the victims of the largest number of religious hate crime offences: 45% of all police-recorded religious hate crimes in England and Wales. It is argued that even this figure obscures the full scale of hate crimes faced by British Muslims, who, like Jews, are targeted on grounds of both race and religion but this only includes religion and not race.
The Four Tiers
Tier One: the common baseline. Every religious community sits, at minimum, on the same formal footing: Articles 9 and 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights, religion or belief as a protected characteristic under the Equality Act 2010, religiously aggravated offences under the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 and the offence of stirring up religious hatred under the Public Order Act 1986. For most, this floor is also the ceiling in law and in practice.
Tier Two: Sikhs and Jews as ethno-religious groups. Sikhs and Jews sit above that floor because of case law rather than legislative design, having been recognised as ethnic/racial groups as well as religious groups. As racial groups, they enjoy the full protection of the harassment provisions in the Equality Act 2010, which include large carve-outs for religion or belief in settings such as services, premises management, schools and associations. Hostility towards them can also be prosecuted as stirring up racial hatred, while Muslims, Buddhists, Hindus and Christians are confined to the narrower religious hatred offence, where the evidential bar is, quite deliberately, much higher.
Tier Three: Jews and the IHRA definition. Since the Government adopted the IHRA working definition of antisemitism in December 2016, Jews have benefited from a further tier of protection. What gives the definition force is a sustained programme of implementation, through an Independent Adviser and a Cabinet Committee on Antisemitism and sector reviews whose recommendations have been promptly accepted by the Government. These are welcome and necessary steps, and a great model for how the UK can tackle other forms of racialised religious bigotry like Islamophobia.
Tier Four: Muslims and the intent threshold. In March 2026, the Government adopted a non-statutory definition that drops the word ‘Islamophobia’ in favour of ‘anti-Muslim hostility’. Unlike the definition of antisemitism, however, it builds intention into every limb of the definition of anti-Muslim hostility – even where the law does not require this, for example, in discrimination and harassment. The IHRA definition, rightly, requires no intent at all for such acts. In multiple ways, therefore, the definition recognises less than the law already prohibits and Muslims are concerned that as it is rolled out to the statutory sector, it may reduce their existing Tier 1 protections in practice, even if not in law. If so, it would leave Muslims at the bottom of the hierarchy of the four tiers. Further, the promised special representative on anti-Muslim hostility has still not been appointed.
Sixteen Shades Of Protection
The four-tier structure described above does not apply uniformly across the UK – as in the UK, criminal law runs under three jurisdictions (England and Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland), discrimination law runs under separate statutory provisions in Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and administrative law and public policy differs in all four nations.
When the four tiers of protection described above are mapped onto the four nations of the UK, it is thus possible to count sixteen different shades of protection for groups facing racialised religious bigotry. These shades will only become more distinct as the non-statutory definitions underlying Tiers 3 and 4 are adopted by public and regulatory bodies in each nation, according to their own legal system, history and public discourse. Each additional shade reinforces the sense that protection depends on who you are, what you believe (or not), and where you live. That makes it harder for communities to see their struggles against hatred as a shared one, and easier for them to be set against each other.
An Urgent Case And Call For Harmonisation
The consequences of this patchwork of protections are not abstract. In the summer of 2024, after the killing of three young girls in Southport and false claims online that the attacker was a Muslim asylum seeker, rioters targeted mosques and Muslims across England. In June 2025, loyalist mobs in Ballymena burned the homes of migrant families, in violence some commentators described as pogroms. Similar violence returned to Belfast and surrounding areas in June 2026, when Amnesty International said anti-Islam sentiment was a more prominent feature of these disturbances than in the past. June 2026 also saw some of the worst violence against Muslims in recent Scottish history. The last three years have also seen major antisemitic attacks on Jewish assets and people – particularly in Manchester and London. Each of these episodes drew a legal and institutional response calibrated by which nation it happened in, which minority was attacked, and therefore, which tier and laws applied to the victims.
When one community sees another’s experience of racialised religious hatred met with a dedicated adviser and reviews accepted by Government, while its own is not, the result can be resentment rather than solidarity. Those dynamics harm everyone, including the communities with the strongest protections. Harmonising protection for racialised religious groups is, therefore, no longer a ‘should’ but a ‘must’. One genuinely equal standard for all should be set at the highest level of protection any community currently enjoys, not the lowest. The principle should be one of levelling up, not levelling down. The Law Commission has recommended that protected characteristics be treated equally across hate crime law, and Parliament has acted on part of that recommendation in the Crime and Policing Act 2026 – it needs to go further.
The progress made in tackling antisemitism is real, hard-won and should be protected and built upon. We strongly support it. Equal protection is not a zero-sum contest: extending the gains made against antisemitism to other communities strengthens, rather than weakens, the case for those gains. MLegal’s Policy Paper on Equality Law Reform, published in May 2026, provides recommendations on how this can be achieved.
For a longer version of this article see: Four Tiers Of Citizenship And Sixteen Shades Of Protection For Groups Facing Racialised Religious Bigotry In The UK
As Islamophobia Awareness Month draws to a close, the case for equal protection has never been more urgent.